Eisenhower Dollar Value and Collectibility

In 1971, following legislation passed the prior year, the U.S. Mint began issuing a $1 coin for the first time since 1935 when the Peace dollar series ended. The new coins, known as Eisenhower dollars, were made in the same copper-nickel composition as the dimes and quarters you receive in change and were the same hefty size as the old silver dollars. They are made of outer layers of .750 copper and .250 nickel bonded to an inner core of pure copper. Continue reading to learn more about Eisenhower dollar value and collectibility.

The coin was issued as a tribute to popular World War II general and former president General Dwight D. Eisenhower, also known as Ike, whose left-facing bust appears on the obverse. The design was inspired by a sketch artist Frank Gasparro made of the general after a 1945 parade for World War II.

The reverse honors the 1969 Apollo 11 landing on the moon and is also designed by Gasparro, who then served as Chief Engraver at the Mint and based it on the Apollo 11 mission patch designed by one of the crew’s members, Michael Collins.

In 1975 the reverse was redesigned by art student Dennis Williams to mark the nation’s bicentennial with dual-dated coins (1975-1976) that show the famous Liberty Bell from Philadelphia in front of the moon, which were issued in 1975 and 1976. Like the quarters and half dollars of this type, they were very popular with the public and collectors.

Dwight D Eisenhower

Dwight D. Eisenhower, often referred to simply as "Ike," was the 34th President of the United States, serving two terms from 1953 to 1961. Born on October 14, 1890, in Denison, Texas, Eisenhower was a significant figure in American military and political history. Here’s an overview of his life, military career, and presidency:

Early Life and Military Career

Eisenhower grew up in Abilene, Kansas, in a poor but religious family. He excelled in sports and later won an appointment to the U.S. Military Academy at West Point, where he graduated in 1915. His early military career was marked by various postings and steady progress through the ranks. During World War I, he was stationed stateside, training tank crews.

World War II

Eisenhower's major career breakthrough came during World War II. In 1942, he was appointed as the commander of the Allied Forces landing in North Africa, known as Operation Torch. His success there led to his promotion to Supreme Commander of the Allied Expeditionary Forces in 1943. In this role, Eisenhower oversaw the planning and execution of Operation Overlord, the Allied invasion of Normandy on June 6, 1944 (D-Day), which was critical in the defeat of Nazi Germany.

Post-War and NATO

After the war, Eisenhower served as Army Chief of Staff and later as the President of Columbia University. He also became the first Supreme Commander of NATO before returning to the U.S. to run for president.

Presidency

Eisenhower's presidency is noted for its moderate political stance. Domestically, he expanded Social Security, initiated the Interstate Highway System, and oversaw the end of the Korean War. His foreign policy was marked by the Cold War dynamics, where he sought to contain the spread of communism, notably supporting the doctrine of massive retaliation against threats by the Soviet Union.

Eisenhower Dollars

150 million Eisenhower dollars were struck in 40% silver for collectors in two versions: mint state Ike dollars in blue envelopes, and Proof Eisenhower dollars sold in plastic cases with a black background which were then placed into a brown box. Thus, there are blue and brown 40% silver Ike dollars as well as silver bicentennial Ikes. Each consists of outer layers of .800 silver and .200 copper that is bonded to an inner core of .209 silver and .791 copper, creating a new silver weight of .3161 ounces.

As a circulating coin, Eisenhower dollars were mostly a failure except in areas of the country like Las Vegas and others that have casinos, where 70% of the clad coins ended up. The first year they were issued, Eisenhower dollars were hoarded by the general public because they were new, and because Ike was so widely admired as a president and wartime leader. But most Americans did not like carrying around large, heavy coins, which is why the series only lasted until 1978. By that time over 640 million of the coins had been struck.

US Mint Production Challenges

From the time the first 1971 Eisenhower dollars were struck, problems were encountered from the stress the large clad coins put on the dies, which resulted in many examples of poor quality. This also led some collectors to acquire rolls of the coins from banks to search for better-quality coins.

In addition, production issues necessitated a reduction in the design’s relief, strengthening of the design and giving the Earth on the reverse better definition.

These changes also resulted in the numerous and complex die varieties that exist of Eisenhower dollars, especially for the 1972 Eisenhower dollars, whose type 2 variety is the series key made in error by using dies intended for proof coins. Only 2,504 of those coins exist.

After almost 300 million coins were made in 1971 and 1972, no circulation coins were needed in 1973, but 1973 and 1973-D coins were made for inclusion in mint sets. Production of circulation coins resumed in 1974. Over 200 million bicentennial dollars dated 1975-1976 were released in 1976, which was followed by the final two years of production at much lower levels than in prior years.

Towards the end of the series, the government concluded that since the large coins did not circulate much, they needed to issue a new dollar coin with a smaller diameter, which led eventually to the Susan B. Anthony dollar’s debut in 1979.

Understudied and Neglected Series

For collectors, Eisenhower dollars remain a favorite modern coin series that can be can be easily if you just want an example of each date, type and mint mark, which can be had for a little over $300. But a full set with major varieties in MS66 is over $20,000!

It is much more challenging to collect if you are interested in scarce die varieties or want each coin in high grade, which gets expensive since a large clad circulation coin has large fields prone to acquiring contact marks. In fact, there are no MS70 Ikes, yet there are coins in the series worth over $10,000.

In terms of the history of U.S. coinage, Eisenhower dollars should be understood in the context of the period when they were issued when the Mint had ceased issuing 90% silver coins because their intrinsic value exceeded their face value. They were issuing copper-nickel coins instead except for the Kennedy half dollar still being made from 40% silver, and the Ike dollar as the largest clad coin ever struck was issued to help keep the Mint relevant to the new era of clad coinage.

But the coin has been underestimated as a collectible ever since it was issued, making it a series that is ripe for discoveries from high-grade examples of the better dates to errors and new varieties. And the main reason there is so much potential in this regard is that the series is endlessly complex when you really get into it and arguably the least well studied and understood modern coin series.

According to CoinWeek editor and Ike dollar expert Charles Morgan, the series is: “the greatest achievement in clad coinage in U.S. history. It was the most technically challenging coin ever attempted (sorry, Saint-Gaudens; your 1907 Double Eagle was spectacular, but try to churn out eighty million Eisenhower dollars on Army surplus presses) leading to a number of modifications and revisions, some of which are only now being identified by experts – and it is a series like this that calls into question how much experts really know about modern coinage.”

In 2012 CAC (the Certified Acceptance Corp.) that reviews the condition of coins to see if they are at the high end for their grade in which case they receive a green sticker -- decided to include silver and clad Ike dollars for this service because of the large disparities that exist in the quality of coins of the same grade.

If you decide to specialize in this great modern series, consider joining the Ike Group, which maintains lots of information on Eisenhower dollars.

Value of Eisenhower Dollars

The value of Eisenhower Dollars can vary significantly based on several factors including the year, mint mark, condition, and whether it is a special silver collector's edition. Here are some key points:

1. Clad Versions vs. Silver Clad Versions
   • Clad Versions: Most Eisenhower Dollars were struck in copper-nickel clad and are generally worth their face value if worn, and a small premium above face value if in uncirculated condition.
   • Silver Clad Versions: The silver versions were produced for collectors and contain 40% silver. These are more valuable, especially in uncirculated or proof conditions.
2. Mint Marks
   • Coins with mint marks like "S" (San Francisco) or "D" (Denver) can sometimes command higher prices. The "S" silver proofs and uncirculated coins are particularly collectible.
3. Special Varieties and Errors
   • Certain rare varieties or error coins, such as the 1972 Type 2 reverse where the Earth appears more rounded and the Florida peninsula is absent, are particularly valuable to collectors.

Collectibility of Eisenhower Dollars

The Eisenhower Dollar is popular among collectors not only for its historical significance but also for its size and design. Collectibility factors include:

• Historical Era: They reflect an important era of American history, capturing both a presidential legacy and a significant national achievement.
• Design: The patriotic designs are appealing to those interested in space exploration and U.S. history.
• Varieties: Collectors appreciate the challenge of assembling complete sets with all the different types, mint marks, and special issues, like the bicentennial commemoratives.
• Affordability: Except for a few rare types, most Eisenhower Dollars are quite affordable, which makes them a popular choice for new collectors.

Tips for Collectors

If you're interested in collecting Eisenhower Dollars, consider the following tips:

• Start with Clad Issues: Begin by collecting the more affordable clad issues before moving to the more expensive silver issues.
• Look for High Grades: Since higher grades (MS-65 and above) can dramatically increase the coin's value, look for well-preserved examples.
• Special Sets: Consider collecting special mint sets or proof sets, which often retain higher long-term value.
• Bicentennial Variants: Don't overlook the bicentennial variants, which can add a unique aspect to your collection.

The most expensive Eisenhower Dollars

The Eisenhower Dollar, while generally not reaching the astronomical values of some other rare U.S. coins, does have certain varieties and conditions that can command significant premiums. Here’s a list of some of the most expensive Eisenhower Dollars, particularly focusing on special strikes or rare varieties:

1972 Type 2 Eisenhower Dollar:

This is one of the most sought-after varieties among Eisenhower Dollar collectors. The Type 2 variety of the 1972 Philadelphia issue features a low-relief earth on the reverse, positioned between the eagle's tail and its lower wing. Uncirculated examples can fetch between $500 and $1,000, while those in MS65 grade can exceed $2,000.

1976 Type 2 Proof Silver Eisenhower Dollar:

 The 1976 Type 2 proofs have clearer and sharper lettering than the Type 1. They were struck in 40% silver and are highly prized by collectors, especially in higher proof grades. Values can range from $50 to over $200, depending on the condition and grading.

1971-S Proof Silver Eisenhower Dollar:

The first of the silver proofs, the 1971-S is valued particularly in high grades. While most proof coins from this year and mint are quite affordable, those graded PR70 by professional grading services can command prices of $5,000 or more.

1973-S Silver Proof Eisenhower Dollar

This proof coin, struck in San Francisco, had a relatively low mintage compared to other years. In flawless condition (PR70), this coin can bring over $3,000 at auction.

1972-S Silver Proof Eisenhower Dollar:

Similar to other silver proofs, but slightly less rare than the 1973-S, the 1972-S in perfect proof condition can also reach values of around $3,000.

1974-S Silver Proof Eisenhower Dollar:

While generally more available than the 1973-S proof, a perfect grade 1974-S Silver Proof can fetch upwards of $1,500.

Special Mint Sets (SMS) Eisenhower Dollars:

Special Mint Set (SMS) coins from 1971-1974, especially those with Cameo or Deep Cameo finishes, are highly collectible. These coins were not circulated and were specially struck with a better finish. Top-graded coins can range from a few hundred to over $1,000.