Gold Buffalo Coin Value

The American  Gold Buffalo coin is one of the most sought-after gold coins in the U.S. Its stunning design, 24-karat gold composition, and historical significance have made it a favorite among collectors. This guide will explore the history of the Gold Buffalo coin, its mintages, market values, top auction records, and why it continues to be in high demand.

The American Gold Buffalo coin was first introduced in 2006 by the U.S. Mint after the passage of the Presidential Dollar Coin Act, as the nation's first-ever 24-karat gold coin. Inspired by the iconic Buffalo Nickel, the coin features the same James Earle Fraser design. The obverse showcases a Native American portrait, while the reverse displays an American bison, often referred to as the buffalo, giving the coin its name.

The Act, passed in 2005, required the U.S. Mint to produce a one ounce gold coin. Specifically, the coin had to carry a $50 denomination and be struck in 24 karat, .9999 pure gold. The main purpose of the American Gold Buffalo was to compete with other world mints that had already produced a 99.99% pure gold coin. Prior to the American Gold Buffalo, the U.S. Mint had only produced the American Gold Eagle which was only 91.67% pure gold, which is 22k. However, the 1 oz American Gold Eagle still contains a whole ounce of gold. Global mints such as the Canadian Mint were stealing thunder from the U.S. Mint until the production of the American Gold Buffalo came into being, and  gold coin collectors would often lean toward the Canadian Gold Maple Leaf which is .9999 pure gold.

Image source: PCGS

Appreciation of Gold Buffalo Coin Prices Over Time

The value of Gold Buffalo coins has appreciated steadily since their release, driven by the increasing price of gold and growing demand for rare, high-quality examples. Key factors influencing this appreciation include:

1. Gold Price Trends: As gold prices rise, the intrinsic value of the Gold Buffalo rises accordingly.
2. Collector Demand: The limited mintage proof coins and special editions have seen significant increases in value as collector demand outstrips supply.
3. Historical Significance: Coins from the first year of issue, as well as unique editions like the Ultra High Relief and Reverse Proof versions, tend to appreciate faster due to their historical significance and lower mintages.

For instance, a 2006 bullion coin that originally sold for around $700 (when gold was under $600/oz) is now worth almost $3,000 due to both the increase in gold prices and the collector premium.

Gold Buffalo Coin Value

The value of an American Gold Buffalo coin is influenced by multiple factors:

1. Gold Spot Price: The market price of gold is the foundation of the coin’s value. Since the coin is made of one ounce of pure gold, its base value will always reflect the current gold spot price.
2. Collector Premiums: Collector interest, mintage numbers, and the coin’s condition (e.g., proof or mint state, certified or raw) can add premiums to its value.

Top Auction Records for Gold Buffalo Coins

Certain Gold Buffalo coins have set impressive auction records due to their rarity and pristine condition. Here are some examples of top-dollar sales:

• 2006-W $50 Burnished Gold Buffalo MS70: This perfect condition coin sold for over $30,000 at auction, setting a high mark for early mint state Buffalo coins.
• 2013-W $50 Reverse Proof 70 First Strike: Selling for around $10,000, this reverse proof coin was in high demand due to its limited mintage and flawless grade.
• 2009 Ultra High Relief Proof 70: A perfect specimen of this coin has fetched over $7,000 at major auctions.

The highest prices tend to be for coins in MS70 or PR70 condition (perfect grades), especially those with early release labels or first-strike designations.

Shop Gold Buffalo coins here>

Gold Buffalo Design

The design of the American Gold Buffalo was taken from the original Buffalo Nickel that was made in 1913. The original Buffalo Nickel was designed by James Earl Fraser and featured a Native American on the obverse of the coin and a bison on the reverse of the coin. The bison on the reverse of the coin was rumored to be “Black Diamond,” who was a popular buffalo in the New York Central Park Zoo. The modern day American Gold Buffalo is a larger replica of the original Buffalo Nickel design.

Gold Buffalo Types

The  U.S. Mint, specifically the West Point Mint has made Gold Buffaloes every year since 2006. Each year, a mint state version and a proof version of the Gold Buffalo has been made. Typically all Gold Buffaloes are 1oz coins, however in 2008 the West Point Mint changed things up and issued a Burnished Gold Buffalo Set and a Proof Gold Buffalo Set. This was the only time the U.S. Mint has done this to date. The 2008 Gold Buffalo Sets consisted of a tenth, quarter, half, and full ounce Gold Buffalo. 2008 marked the only year the Mint has done fractional Gold Buffaloes as well as a Burnished Gold Buffalo.

American Gold Buffalo Specifications

● .9999 pure gold

● Struck at the West Point Mint

● 1 oz weight

● 32.7mm diameter (1oz), 27mm (1/2oz), 22mm (1/4oz), 16.5 (1/10oz)

Most In-Demand American Gold Buffalo Coins

Several Gold Buffalo coins stand out as particularly desirable among collectors. Here are a few of the most in-demand versions:

• 2006-W Proof Gold Buffalo: As the first year of issue and proof version, this coin is highly coveted. It set the standard for future releases.
• 2009 Ultra High Relief: This unique issue, produced in ultra-high relief, offers a different texture and depth compared to standard releases.
• 2013-W Reverse Proof: Celebrating the 100th anniversary of the Buffalo Nickel, this reverse proof is one of the most aesthetically striking versions of the Gold Buffalo.

Due to their rarity and historical significance, these versions tend to appreciate more over time compared to standard bullion coins.

Shop  Gold Buffalo coins here>

FAQ

What is a Gold Buffalo coin?

The Gold Buffalo coin is a 24-karat gold coin issued by the U.S. Mint. It was first introduced in 2006 and is the first American coin struck in pure .9999 fine gold. The design is based on the iconic Buffalo Nickel, featuring a Native American portrait on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse. It is one of the most popular gold coins in the U.S. due to its purity and historical design.

How much is a Gold Buffalo coin worth?

The value of a Gold Buffalo coin is primarily based on the current gold spot price, as the coin contains one troy ounce of pure gold. For example, if gold is trading at $2,000 per ounce, the coin's intrinsic value would have a small premium. However, depending on its condition (uncirculated, proof, or certified) and year, certain versions can command premiums over the gold price. Proof and rare collectible edition coins can be worth much more, sometimes fetching $3,000 or more at auctions.

Are Gold Buffalo coins pure gold?

Yes, Gold Buffalo coins are made of pure 24-karat gold with a fineness of .9999. This makes them one of the purest gold coins issued by the U.S. Mint. Unlike American Gold Eagles, which are struck in 22-karat gold, Gold Buffalo coins contain no alloy metals and are made from 100% gold.

Can I buy Gold Buffalo coins directly from the U.S. Mint?

The U.S. Mint does not sell bullion versions of the Gold Buffalo coin directly to the public. Instead, it sells to authorized dealers who then distribute them to consumers. However, the U.S. Mint does offer proof versions of the Gold Buffalo coin for sale directly on their website, typically at a premium above the spot price of gold.

What is the highest price ever paid for a Gold Buffalo coin?

The highest prices for Gold Buffalo coins are typically for perfectly graded coins (MS70 or PR70) or special editions. Some notable auction records include:

• A 2006-W $50 Burnished Gold Buffalo MS70 selling for over $30,000.
• A 2013-W Reverse Proof 70 First Strike fetching around $10,000 at auction. The highest auction prices generally reflect the rarity and condition of the coin, as well as any special features like early release labels or first-strike designations.

Learn more about: which quarters are worth money, how many nickels in a roll, 1953 wheat penny value, quarters worth money, pennies worth money, 1942 penny value, what are nickels made of, most valuable quarters, 1945 wheat penny value, Morgan silver dollars, silver American eagles, 2024 silver eagle coins, burnished silver eagle coins, franklin half dollar.