Peace Dollar Medal Recreates Original Design for Coin

2021 marks the centennial of the debut of one of the most popular U.S. coins of all time – the  Peace silver dollar – which was issued to commemorate the end of what until then was the worst war in human history and is now an icon of 20 ^th century coinage that even inspired a modern Canadian Peace dollar almost 100 years later.

Designed by Italian-born American artist Anthony de Francisci, the Peace dollar coin has a fascinating backstory. In fact, the actual design used on the coin from 1921 to 1935 is not the same as the one first struck in late 1921 that was modified and which included a motif used in an alternate reverse design the artist had prepared along with a slightly different obverse design.

Those original designs that have never been issued as coins have now been struck in a beautiful  two-ounce, .999 silver medal in amazing ultra-high-relief on both sides and a Reverse Proof finish with a mintage limited to 1,921 coins and which are authorized and approved by the Smithsonian Institution. And they are available now graded PF70 by NGC.

Origins of the Coin

Back in November 1918 when the armistice ending the fighting in World War but before the formal end of the war, an article was published in December of that year in The Numismatist, the official magazine of the American Numismatic Association, that proposed a victory coin be issued as a silver dollar.

In 1920, coin dealer and former ANA president Farran Zerbe developed the idea more fully as a commemorative coin to be sold at face value to demonstrate America’s commitment to peace. Since the 1918 Pittman Act called for the resumption of striking silver dollars using silver purchased from Western American mines, the coin would be a silver dollar instead of a half dollar. The ANA established a committee for this program, which then lobbied the House Coinage Committee.

As the ANA worked with Congress to get a bill passed that had been introduced May 9, one roadblock was that the U.S. had not yet formally declared peace with Germany, which only happened in a congressional resolution in the summer of 1921, which meant the coin could not be issued until the new Harding administration took office. As for the legislation, none was required because once a coin design has been used for at least 25 years as the Morgan dollar had, it can be changed by the Treasury with congressional approval.

The Commission on Fine Arts, which reviewed coin designs and made recommendations to the Treasury secretary, got involved, and the Treasury decided to hold a design competition similar to one for the Verdun medal for which de Francisci had submitted a design.

Although he was younger – only 33 at the time --, thought he would not win and was much less experienced than the seven other designers who submitted their designs for the coin that included people like the legendary Adolph Weinman, Victor D. Brenner and James Earle Fraser with him de Francisci had worked before, his design was selected.

The specifications for the design simply said they had to be “representative of peace or limitations of armaments. It also said the obverse should carry a Liberty head similar to the one on the Morgan dollar “but made as beautiful and full of character as possible” and the coin should be “decidedly American in spirit.”

The new coin would be known as the Peace dollar and is the only American coin to carry that word to this day.

Artist’s Designs

In his submissions, de Francisci decided to submit two different reverse designs and an obverse design similar to what was later used on the actual coin but with the date in Roman numerals and “different modelling of Liberty’s chin and mouth,” making them less prominent, as Roger Burdette has explained.

As for the two reverses – one was of a benign eagle holding not olive and oak as on most U.S. coins to symbolize peace through strength but instead only an olive branch for peace, and a second design featured an aggressive-looking eagle breaking a sword in its mouth.

The obverse was partly inspired by the statue of Victory by Augustus Saint-Gaudens on his monument to Civil War General Sherman in New York City but with his new wife Theresa serving as the model, which became her claim to fame that was noted in her obituary when she passed in 1990 at 92, while the artist died in 1964.

He decided to go with the reverse showing an eagle perched on a mountain top viewing the dawn of peace on the horizon as symbolized by rays in the background. However, while he opted not to use the different reverse design he prepared as far as the eagle itself, he did incorporate the broken sword from the other design showing the eagle clutching that and olive. The broken sword was intended to symbolize destroying the implement of war, and a model using that version was approved by President Harding on December 20. A bronze cast was struck.

The sword later became controversial following the publication of an editorial in The New York Herald on December 21, which argued it implied defeat and mercy, leading to the sending of numerous letters to the Treasury protesting the design and was removed by Chief Engraver Charles Morgan on December 23 with the artist supervising the altering of the die.

Interestingly, the artist’s wife noted in a 1981 New York Times piece that the judges of the design competition liked both of the artist’s reverse designs and voted first for the one never used that has now been recreated on the 2021 silver medal. That decision was rescinded, and the judges opted for the one with the more passive eagle.

It’s important to keep in mind that all of this happened very quickly. The call for designs had only gone out in November, giving the artist little time to do all this and giving the Mint little time to strike the coins after those modifications were made. When that did happen at the end of 1921, problems were encountered with striking the coins in high-relief, which is why the  1921 Peace dollar is the one in the series, and the only American silver coin. made in that stunning relief.