2009 Penny Error List

2009 marked both the bicentennial of Abraham Lincoln’s birth and the centennial of the Lincoln cent itself. Continue reading to learn more about 2009 penny error list.

To celebrate, the U.S. Mint replaced the long-standing Memorial reverse with four one-year designs that trace Lincoln’s life:

Each design required new working hubs and dies—and the frantic pace of striking 2.35 billion cents in just 11 monthscreated perfect conditions for doubled dies, die chips, cracks, off-centre strikes, wrong-planchet hits and other mishaps. Variety specialists now recognise well over 120 distinct doubled-die listings for 2009 alone Doubled Die. Learn how these varieties affect 2009 lincoln wheat penny value.

2009 Penny Error List

Below is a collector-favourite “short list” of important errors and their influence on 2009 penny value. Where PCGS or Heritage has published an auction price, the record is shown for context (all prices are for red Mint State examples unless noted). 

1. Birth & Early Childhood (“Log Cabin”)

   Variety	What to look for	Auction highlight
   DDO FS-101 (P-mint)	Bold spread on LIBERTY and the date	$65 in MS65RD (eBay, 2022) eBay
   DDR WDDR-021 (P-mint)	Extra log ends under the cabin porch	$32 in MS65RD (eBay, 2021) eBay
   Off-centre strikes (P & D)	Design missing along part of the rim; 5-15 % is most common	$100-$250 depending on percent off-centre and grade

2. Formative Years (“Extra-Thumb/Extra-Finger” coins)

   This is the error hot-spot of 2009: at least 60 separate doubled-die reverses show extra digits on Lincoln’s right hand as he holds the book Doubled Die.

   Variety (FS-#)	Extra digit position	Auction record
   FS-801 (P)	Second index finger above the normal one	$112 in MS66RD (eBay, 2021) PCGS
   FS-803 (D)	Large raised “thumb” on the book spine	$51 in MS65RD (Heritage, 2019) PCGS
   FS-807 (P)	Two distinct doubled areas (obv. & rev.)	$33 in MS65RD (eBay, 2018) PCGS

   

   AUCTION RECORD: $112

   Grade: MS66RD

   Sold: 08-26-2021

   Other notable errors on this design:

   • Clipped planchets—curved crescent missing from the rim; $20-$75 in high grade.

   • Die cracks running through the boots and log—collectible at $5-$15 each Doubled Die.

3. Professional Life

   While fewer doubled dies are known than for Formative Years, the best pieces still command premiums.

   Variety	Diagnostic	Value notes
   WDDO-001 to WDDO-005 (P-mint)	Thick, notched letters in LIBERTY; look with 10× glass	Choice BU coins trade in the $25-$60 range.
   WDDR-001 (P-mint)	Doubling under the third window of the Illinois State House	Raw MS examples realise $40-$70 on eBay.
   MS68RD “top-pop” grade rarity (D-mint)	No variety—just pristine surfaces	$1,490 in MS68RD (only two graded) PCGS

   Common strike-throughs (grease filled letters) on AMERICA and ONE CENT sell for $3-$10.

4. Presidency in Washington

   The last design produced the fewest high-visibility varieties, but doubled dies and spectacular die gouges exist.

   Variety	Spot the error	Typical prices
   WDDR-001 to -003 (P-mint)	Doubling on the unfinished Capitol dome scaffolding	$20-$45 in MS65RD
   Die-gouge pillar (D-mint)	Vertical “spike” from the base of the dome	One sold MS60BN for $45 in 2024.
   Massive die crack through the building (D-mint)	Looks like lightning; dramatic cracks reach $15-$30 raw

   ---

Other 2009 cent error categories to watch for

How to hunt and confirm a 2009‐cent error

1. Use adequate magnification – a 10× loupe is minimum; a 20-60× USB microscope helps with subtle extra-thumb varieties.

2. Target areas first:

   • Log ends on the Birthplace reverse.

   • Lincoln’s right hand and book (Formative Years).

   • Third-row windows on the Professional Life reverse.

   • Base of the Capitol dome on the Presidency reverse.

3. Compare to trusted references – Wexler’s Doubled-Die Files and CONECA’s Variety Vista keep photo archives of every listed variety.

4. Weigh suspicious coins – wrong-planchet pieces deviate from the 2.50 g zinc standard by more than ±0.15 g.

5. Grade before you sell – PCGS/NGC certification turns a $20 raw error into $75-$150 once encapsulated, and stabilises thin copper surfaces.

Recent market performance

Even in a soft modern-coin market, premium pieces bring solid money:

• 2009-D Formative Years MS67RD FS-801 – $480 (Heritage, 2022)

• 2009-P Presidency DDR MS66RD – $216 (eBay, 2023)

• Complete 4-coin set, each with certified DDR – routinely fetches $325-$400.

Frequently asked questions

Are 2009 pennies copper or zinc?
Business-strike 2009 cents are the usual copper-plated zinc alloy (2.5 g), but the S-mint proofs and the uncirculated Mint-set satin coins were struck in the pre-1982 “bronze” alloy (95 % copper, 3.11 g). Errors occur on both compositions. PCGS

Which 2009 penny error is worth the most?
So far the top price belongs to a Birthplace MS67+RD that hammered for $646 at Heritage in 2015, primarily for condition rather than variety PCGS. Among doubled dies, the P-mint FS-801 extra-thumb has generated the highest certified-grade premiums.

How many extra-thumb varieties exist?
Depending on the counting method, 40-60 separate listings (WDDR-, CONECA DDR-, FS- numbers) show extra digits on the Formative Years reverse; new dies are still being reported. 

Do I have to pay tax when I sell?
Modern cents are not exempt from capital-gains tax; consult a tax professional if profits exceed hobby limits.